5 methods to make nugget ice at home: A complete guide

What is nugget ice?

Also known as pellet ice or pebble ice, nugget ice cubes are smaller in size and have a chewy, “soft” texture. Instead of freezing a solid block of ice, nugget ice is made by compressing ice flakes into a cylindrical or pebble-like shape, resulting in air trapped between layers. Because it’s got more air in it than regular ice cubes, nugget ice is perfect for chewing. And since nugget ice has a higher surface area than ice cubes, it often cools your drink even faster.

Why is nugget ice so popular?

Initially popularized by fast-food chains, nugget ice has become popular due to its pleasant texture and flavor-absorbing qualities, Unlike traditional hard cubes or bullet ice, its porous composition allows it to soak up the flavor of the beverage it chills, offering a flavorful "crunch" at the end of a drink. 

This soft consistency also makes it a favorite in healthcare settings for hydration and among enthusiasts who prefer "the good ice" for its ability to chill drinks rapidly without being harsh on teeth.

Nugget ice vs. traditional cubed ice

There are a few key differences between nugget ice and traditional ice cubes. The traditional ice cube shape is large and solid, making it difficult to blend and tough to chew. Nugget ice is well known for being “chewable” due to its content, which includes more air than regular ice. Its smaller size and larger surface area (compared to regular ice) help it to cool drinks faster, but consequently, it also melts a little quicker than traditional ice cubes.

5 methods to make nugget ice at home

There are multiple ways to make nugget ice at home to keep on hand for cocktail parties and after-school hangouts. These methods range from dedicated ice makers to DIY techniques. Learn how to make nugget ice with the five methods below.

Method 1: Countertop nugget ice maker

Countertop ice makers are a common choice for those who want to bring the drive-thru to their kitchen. These appliances sit on your counter and can produce a bucket of nugget ice fairly quickly. This can be a good option for small kitchens, but these ice makers often offer limited production capacity due to their size and take up space on your countertop.

Method 2: Undercounter nugget ice machine

Similar to countertop nugget ice makers, undercounter nugget ice machines are a dedicated ice making appliance. These models are installed under your counter between your kitchen cabinetry and offer a larger production capacity than countertop options. They’re a great choice for homes that frequently host parties and gatherings and can be conveniently installed beneath a wet bar. However, these appliances do require a dedicated water line and take up valuable cabinet space.

Method 3: Refrigerator with built-in nugget ice

If you don’t want another appliance taking up space in your kitchen, you may want to upgrade your refrigerator to a model with a built-in nugget ice maker. Whirlpool brand will soon be introducing the industry’s first refrigerator with an in-door nugget ice maker. Get craveworthy, soft, chewable ice straight from the fridge. The built-in nugget ice maker holds up to 2.4 lbs of ice, and it can even be removed for easy scooping. Plus, the anti-clumping tech makes sure you get individual nuggets, not clusters.

Method 4: DIY carbonated water method

If getting a new appliance isn’t in the budget right now, you can still enjoy a similar texture to nugget ice by freezing carbonated water. The bubbles from the carbonation leave air pockets in the ice, helping to produce the chewy texture. 

Pour the carbonated water into an ice tray, filling the pockets about halfway. Keep in the freezer until frozen solid, then crush the ice using a muddling tool. It’s not going to be a perfect replication, but this DIY method can help satisfy the craving.

Method 5: Crushing and shaving technique

Another DIY option that doesn’t require a dedicated ice maker is simply making traditional ice and crushing it using a plastic bag and a mallet or the ice crusher setting on a blender. While this method technically creates crushed ice, not nugget ice, it’s a budget-friendly option that only requires a little bit of elbow grease to create a somewhat similar size.

Nugget ice method comparison

Which method is right for you?

Whether you choose a dedicated nugget ice maker, a DIY method or the refrigerator with built-in nugget ice from Whirlpool brand depends on your family’s budget and preferences. If you frequently host parties or after-school study sessions, you may want to consider a fridge with nugget ice capabilities or an undercounter or built-in option that can keep large batches of nugget ice on hand.

If you’re only trying to satisfy a craving every once in a while, the DIY methods using crushed ice or carbonated water can be a budget-friendly option.

FAQs about nugget ice

If you’re still curious about nugget ice, explore the frequently asked questions below to learn more.

Is nugget ice the same as drive-thru ice?

Yes, some fast-food restaurants do in fact use chewy, soft nugget ice in their beverages. Fast-food chains offering nugget ice have helped popularized nugget ice for home use.

Do you have to use distilled water for nugget ice?

You don’t have to use distilled water to make deliciously chewy nugget ice, but using filtered water may improve ice quality and taste while possibly reducing mineral buildup in your ice maker.

How long does nugget ice last before melting?

Melting speed of ice depends on a variety of factors, including environment and the temperature of the liquid being poured over it. While nugget ice tends to melt faster than traditional ice cubes due to its larger surface area, nugget ice usually melts slower than crushed or shaved ice.

Explore Whirlpool^® Refrigerators

Whether you want a fridge with an in-door nugget ice maker, or a French door model to easily store and organize your family’s favorites, Whirlpool brand has refrigerator options for every home. Explore the Whirlpool^® lineup to find the right fit for your kitchen.